Test Set Results:  Aniso. Diff. (Color) | Aniso. Diff. (Grayscale) | Curve Evolution (Grayscale)

Curve Evolution

Test Set Segmentation Results (100 images)

  Geodesic Active Contours (GAC) Gradient Vector Flow (GVF) Edgeflow with offset 4*sigma (EFC') Edgeflow with offset sigma (EFC2')
ID: 101085 Recall=0.69, Precision=0.59
F=0.64		 Recall=0.59, Precision=0.68
F=0.63		 Recall=0.68, Precision=0.69
F=0.68		 Recall=0.64, Precision=0.78
F=0.70
ID: 101087 Recall=0.58, Precision=0.69
F=0.63		 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.76
F=0.59		 Recall=0.46, Precision=0.84
F=0.59		 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.78
F=0.58
ID: 102061 Recall=0.41, Precision=0.41
F=0.41		 Recall=0.35, Precision=0.51
F=0.42		 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.53
F=0.50		 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.45
F=0.45
ID: 103070 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.45
F=0.48		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.52
F=0.44		 Recall=0.50, Precision=0.52
F=0.51		 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.50
F=0.50
ID: 105025 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.36
F=0.44		 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.41
F=0.44		 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.50
F=0.53		 Recall=0.61, Precision=0.45
F=0.52
ID: 106024 Recall=0.58, Precision=0.56
F=0.57		 Recall=0.41, Precision=0.66
F=0.51		 Recall=0.62, Precision=0.50
F=0.55		 Recall=0.53, Precision=0.56
F=0.54
ID: 108005 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.44
F=0.45		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.48
F=0.43		 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.56
F=0.49		 Recall=0.54, Precision=0.53
F=0.54
ID: 108070 Recall=0.22, Precision=0.24
F=0.23		 Recall=0.14, Precision=0.27
F=0.18		 Recall=0.25, Precision=0.28
F=0.26		 Recall=0.24, Precision=0.26
F=0.25
ID: 108082 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.25
F=0.34		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.25
F=0.31		 Recall=0.41, Precision=0.30
F=0.35		 Recall=0.42, Precision=0.29
F=0.35
ID: 109053 Recall=0.40, Precision=0.36
F=0.38		 Recall=0.31, Precision=0.41
F=0.35		 Recall=0.38, Precision=0.36
F=0.37		 Recall=0.50, Precision=0.39
F=0.44
ID: 119082 Recall=0.55, Precision=0.72
F=0.63		 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.78
F=0.61		 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.81
F=0.61		 Recall=0.53, Precision=0.83
F=0.65
ID: 12084 Recall=0.25, Precision=0.22
F=0.23		 Recall=0.32, Precision=0.26
F=0.29		 Recall=0.36, Precision=0.31
F=0.33		 Recall=0.38, Precision=0.28
F=0.32
ID: 123074 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.24
F=0.34		 Recall=0.53, Precision=0.31
F=0.39		 Recall=0.57, Precision=0.32
F=0.41		 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.30
F=0.39
ID: 126007 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.65
F=0.53		 Recall=0.29, Precision=0.67
F=0.41		 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.64
F=0.52		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.66
F=0.49
ID: 130026 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.32
F=0.35		 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.32
F=0.37		 Recall=0.42, Precision=0.35
F=0.38		 Recall=0.50, Precision=0.33
F=0.40
ID: 134035 Recall=0.50, Precision=0.63
F=0.56		 Recall=0.37, Precision=0.69
F=0.48		 Recall=0.42, Precision=0.73
F=0.53		 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.70
F=0.53
ID: 14037 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.77
F=0.59		 Recall=0.35, Precision=0.63
F=0.45		 Recall=0.50, Precision=0.78
F=0.61		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.74
F=0.61
ID: 143090 Recall=0.59, Precision=0.70
F=0.64		 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.75
F=0.57		 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.62
F=0.59		 Recall=0.61, Precision=0.63
F=0.62
ID: 145086 Recall=0.73, Precision=0.62
F=0.67		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.67
F=0.59		 Recall=0.62, Precision=0.81
F=0.71		 Recall=0.65, Precision=0.84
F=0.73
ID: 147091 Recall=0.65, Precision=0.62
F=0.63		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.66
F=0.58		 Recall=0.62, Precision=0.74
F=0.68		 Recall=0.64, Precision=0.74
F=0.69
ID: 148026 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.44
F=0.49		 Recall=0.57, Precision=0.49
F=0.53		 Recall=0.53, Precision=0.47
F=0.50		 Recall=0.59, Precision=0.48
F=0.53
ID: 148089 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.53
F=0.52		 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.54
F=0.48		 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.55
F=0.56		 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.50
F=0.49
ID: 156065 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.38
F=0.41		 Recall=0.42, Precision=0.43
F=0.43		 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.44
F=0.46		 Recall=0.57, Precision=0.45
F=0.50
ID: 157055 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.78
F=0.65		 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.74
F=0.55		 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.78
F=0.60		 Recall=0.50, Precision=0.80
F=0.62
ID: 159008 Recall=0.54, Precision=0.52
F=0.53		 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.56
F=0.52		 Recall=0.54, Precision=0.54
F=0.54		 Recall=0.58, Precision=0.52
F=0.55
ID: 160068 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.34
F=0.40		 Recall=0.37, Precision=0.36
F=0.37		 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.41
F=0.45		 Recall=0.53, Precision=0.41
F=0.46
ID: 16077 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.44
F=0.47		 Recall=0.42, Precision=0.50
F=0.45		 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.48
F=0.46		 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.45
F=0.45
ID: 163085 Recall=0.17, Precision=0.27
F=0.21		 Recall=0.24, Precision=0.36
F=0.29		 Recall=0.34, Precision=0.33
F=0.33		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.42
F=0.41
ID: 167062 Recall=0.80, Precision=0.85
F=0.82		 Recall=0.80, Precision=0.80
F=0.80		 Recall=0.65, Precision=0.94
F=0.77		 Recall=0.79, Precision=0.94
F=0.86
ID: 167083 Recall=0.62, Precision=0.46
F=0.53		 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.51
F=0.49		 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.56
F=0.52		 Recall=0.53, Precision=0.56
F=0.54
ID: 170057 Recall=0.22, Precision=0.49
F=0.31		 Recall=0.26, Precision=0.53
F=0.35		 Recall=0.33, Precision=0.55
F=0.41		 Recall=0.37, Precision=0.52
F=0.43
ID: 175032 Recall=0.34, Precision=0.49
F=0.40		 Recall=0.35, Precision=0.48
F=0.41		 Recall=0.40, Precision=0.49
F=0.44		 Recall=0.42, Precision=0.50
F=0.46
ID: 175043 Recall=0.37, Precision=0.63
F=0.47		 Recall=0.31, Precision=0.65
F=0.42		 Recall=0.34, Precision=0.66
F=0.45		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.64
F=0.49
ID: 182053 Recall=0.37, Precision=0.66
F=0.47		 Recall=0.35, Precision=0.62
F=0.44		 Recall=0.42, Precision=0.64
F=0.51		 Recall=0.40, Precision=0.60
F=0.48
ID: 189080 Recall=0.75, Precision=0.59
F=0.66		 Recall=0.61, Precision=0.60
F=0.61		 Recall=0.70, Precision=0.72
F=0.71		 Recall=0.74, Precision=0.69
F=0.71
ID: 19021 Recall=0.64, Precision=0.70
F=0.67		 Recall=0.50, Precision=0.76
F=0.60		 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.83
F=0.67		 Recall=0.54, Precision=0.80
F=0.65
ID: 196073 Recall=0.27, Precision=0.67
F=0.38		 Recall=0.18, Precision=0.74
F=0.28		 Recall=0.35, Precision=0.79
F=0.49		 Recall=0.60, Precision=0.43
F=0.50
ID: 197017 Recall=0.57, Precision=0.59
F=0.58		 Recall=0.50, Precision=0.66
F=0.57		 Recall=0.64, Precision=0.79
F=0.71		 Recall=0.59, Precision=0.79
F=0.67
ID: 208001 Recall=0.33, Precision=0.66
F=0.44		 Recall=0.24, Precision=0.85
F=0.37		 Recall=0.33, Precision=0.88
F=0.48		 Recall=0.34, Precision=0.86
F=0.48
ID: 210088 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.36
F=0.44		 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.42
F=0.45		 Recall=0.57, Precision=0.39
F=0.47		 Recall=0.57, Precision=0.37
F=0.45
ID: 21077 Recall=0.60, Precision=0.63
F=0.61		 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.68
F=0.56		 Recall=0.50, Precision=0.69
F=0.58		 Recall=0.54, Precision=0.65
F=0.59
ID: 216081 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.80
F=0.63		 Recall=0.34, Precision=0.84
F=0.49		 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.92
F=0.59		 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.93
F=0.60
ID: 219090 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.57
F=0.57		 Recall=0.41, Precision=0.58
F=0.48		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.59
F=0.55		 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.57
F=0.52
ID: 220075 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.52
F=0.50		 Recall=0.38, Precision=0.59
F=0.46		 Recall=0.37, Precision=0.54
F=0.44		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.59
F=0.55
ID: 223061 Recall=0.41, Precision=0.63
F=0.49		 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.68
F=0.53		 Recall=0.59, Precision=0.72
F=0.65		 Recall=0.58, Precision=0.65
F=0.61
ID: 227092 Recall=0.25, Precision=0.90
F=0.40		 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.78
F=0.62		 Recall=0.62, Precision=0.87
F=0.72		 Recall=0.58, Precision=0.87
F=0.69
ID: 229036 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.42
F=0.48		 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.48
F=0.48		 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.61
F=0.54		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.55
F=0.53
ID: 236037 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.39
F=0.41		 Recall=0.33, Precision=0.37
F=0.35		 Recall=0.40, Precision=0.38
F=0.39		 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.39
F=0.43
ID: 24077 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.64
F=0.53		 Recall=0.37, Precision=0.64
F=0.47		 Recall=0.46, Precision=0.67
F=0.55		 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.60
F=0.50
ID: 241004 Recall=0.73, Precision=0.68
F=0.71		 Recall=0.60, Precision=0.69
F=0.64		 Recall=0.73, Precision=0.77
F=0.75		 Recall=0.72, Precision=0.79
F=0.75
ID: 241048 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.66
F=0.58		 Recall=0.40, Precision=0.67
F=0.50		 Recall=0.46, Precision=0.71
F=0.56		 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.66
F=0.56
ID: 253027 Recall=0.40, Precision=0.53
F=0.45		 Recall=0.20, Precision=0.53
F=0.29		 Recall=0.14, Precision=0.82
F=0.24		 Recall=0.35, Precision=0.47
F=0.40
ID: 253055 Recall=0.40, Precision=0.41
F=0.41		 Recall=0.34, Precision=0.52
F=0.41		 Recall=0.34, Precision=0.46
F=0.39		 Recall=0.33, Precision=0.40
F=0.36
ID: 260058 Recall=0.23, Precision=0.58
F=0.33		 Recall=0.37, Precision=0.56
F=0.45		 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.62
F=0.56		 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.73
F=0.59
ID: 271035 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.57
F=0.54		 Recall=0.42, Precision=0.63
F=0.50		 Recall=0.57, Precision=0.64
F=0.60		 Recall=0.55, Precision=0.62
F=0.59
ID: 285079 Recall=0.60, Precision=0.71
F=0.65		 Recall=0.40, Precision=0.68
F=0.50		 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.80
F=0.56		 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.72
F=0.56
ID: 291000 Recall=0.60, Precision=0.44
F=0.51		 Recall=0.53, Precision=0.47
F=0.50		 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.46
F=0.45		 Recall=0.62, Precision=0.47
F=0.53
ID: 295087 Recall=0.37, Precision=0.62
F=0.46		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.59
F=0.47		 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.61
F=0.53		 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.61
F=0.53
ID: 296007 Recall=0.21, Precision=0.62
F=0.32		 Recall=0.35, Precision=0.63
F=0.45		 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.65
F=0.55		 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.63
F=0.51
ID: 296059 Recall=0.72, Precision=0.70
F=0.71		 Recall=0.67, Precision=0.73
F=0.70		 Recall=0.68, Precision=0.70
F=0.69		 Recall=0.69, Precision=0.79
F=0.74
ID: 299086 Recall=0.34, Precision=0.85
F=0.48		 Recall=0.32, Precision=0.75
F=0.45		 Recall=0.37, Precision=0.80
F=0.50		 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.69
F=0.54
ID: 300091 Recall=0.64, Precision=0.44
F=0.52		 Recall=0.58, Precision=0.60
F=0.59		 Recall=0.64, Precision=0.61
F=0.62		 Recall=0.62, Precision=0.56
F=0.59
ID: 302008 Recall=0.57, Precision=0.62
F=0.59		 Recall=0.50, Precision=0.61
F=0.55		 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.69
F=0.57		 Recall=0.50, Precision=0.86
F=0.63
ID: 304034 Recall=0.54, Precision=0.19
F=0.29		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.25
F=0.34		 Recall=0.53, Precision=0.24
F=0.33		 Recall=0.59, Precision=0.20
F=0.30
ID: 304074 Recall=0.62, Precision=0.42
F=0.50		 Recall=0.59, Precision=0.40
F=0.47		 Recall=0.65, Precision=0.52
F=0.58		 Recall=0.66, Precision=0.49
F=0.56
ID: 306005 Recall=0.55, Precision=0.60
F=0.57		 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.60
F=0.50		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.79
F=0.62		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.79
F=0.63
ID: 3096 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.76
F=0.56		 Recall=0.37, Precision=0.86
F=0.52		 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.81
F=0.62		 Recall=0.54, Precision=0.67
F=0.60
ID: 33039 Recall=0.55, Precision=0.44
F=0.49		 Recall=0.36, Precision=0.47
F=0.41		 Recall=0.58, Precision=0.46
F=0.51		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.42
F=0.46
ID: 351093 Recall=0.53, Precision=0.55
F=0.54		 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.57
F=0.51		 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.70
F=0.58		 Recall=0.53, Precision=0.66
F=0.59
ID: 361010 Recall=0.55, Precision=0.53
F=0.54		 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.65
F=0.52		 Recall=0.41, Precision=0.70
F=0.52		 Recall=0.53, Precision=0.67
F=0.59
ID: 37073 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.81
F=0.61		 Recall=0.36, Precision=0.83
F=0.50		 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.80
F=0.58		 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.78
F=0.60
ID: 376043 Recall=0.61, Precision=0.38
F=0.47		 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.44
F=0.44		 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.44
F=0.47		 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.42
F=0.48
ID: 38082 Recall=0.46, Precision=0.52
F=0.49		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.49
F=0.44		 Recall=0.42, Precision=0.53
F=0.47		 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.49
F=0.48
ID: 38092 Recall=0.54, Precision=0.55
F=0.55		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.66
F=0.58		 Recall=0.59, Precision=0.64
F=0.61		 Recall=0.59, Precision=0.62
F=0.61
ID: 385039 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.63
F=0.59		 Recall=0.40, Precision=0.65
F=0.50		 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.63
F=0.57		 Recall=0.40, Precision=0.63
F=0.49
ID: 41033 Recall=0.60, Precision=0.60
F=0.60		 Recall=0.61, Precision=0.59
F=0.60		 Recall=0.54, Precision=0.71
F=0.62		 Recall=0.63, Precision=0.72
F=0.67
ID: 41069 Recall=0.65, Precision=0.58
F=0.61		 Recall=0.34, Precision=0.60
F=0.44		 Recall=0.61, Precision=0.58
F=0.59		 Recall=0.66, Precision=0.57
F=0.61
ID: 42012 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.58
F=0.52		 Recall=0.44, Precision=0.67
F=0.53		 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.62
F=0.51		 Recall=0.30, Precision=0.63
F=0.41
ID: 42049 Recall=0.70, Precision=0.87
F=0.77		 Recall=0.57, Precision=0.96
F=0.72		 Recall=0.73, Precision=0.90
F=0.81		 Recall=0.70, Precision=0.85
F=0.76
ID: 43074 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.53
F=0.48		 Recall=0.22, Precision=0.62
F=0.33		 Recall=0.60, Precision=0.33
F=0.43		 Recall=0.63, Precision=0.31
F=0.41
ID: 45096 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.80
F=0.63		 Recall=0.13, Precision=0.72
F=0.22		 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.83
F=0.64		 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.83
F=0.63
ID: 54082 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.65
F=0.57		 Recall=0.29, Precision=0.66
F=0.40		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.61
F=0.48		 Recall=0.37, Precision=0.57
F=0.45
ID: 55073 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.43
F=0.43		 Recall=0.30, Precision=0.52
F=0.38		 Recall=0.41, Precision=0.59
F=0.48		 Recall=0.34, Precision=0.62
F=0.44
ID: 58060 Recall=0.33, Precision=0.51
F=0.40		 Recall=0.32, Precision=0.53
F=0.40		 Recall=0.24, Precision=0.62
F=0.34		 Recall=0.29, Precision=0.55
F=0.38
ID: 62096 Recall=0.72, Precision=0.46
F=0.56		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.50
F=0.51		 Recall=0.58, Precision=0.64
F=0.61		 Recall=0.66, Precision=0.72
F=0.69
ID: 65033 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.62
F=0.55		 Recall=0.36, Precision=0.76
F=0.49		 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.72
F=0.56		 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.72
F=0.57
ID: 66053 Recall=0.58, Precision=0.57
F=0.58		 Recall=0.35, Precision=0.61
F=0.45		 Recall=0.33, Precision=0.69
F=0.44		 Recall=0.34, Precision=0.64
F=0.45
ID: 69015 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.71
F=0.57		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.76
F=0.52		 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.81
F=0.58		 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.77
F=0.62
ID: 69020 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.48
F=0.49		 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.50
F=0.47		 Recall=0.55, Precision=0.60
F=0.57		 Recall=0.61, Precision=0.62
F=0.62
ID: 69040 Recall=0.36, Precision=0.33
F=0.34		 Recall=0.31, Precision=0.37
F=0.34		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.37
F=0.38		 Recall=0.38, Precision=0.34
F=0.36
ID: 76053 Recall=0.35, Precision=0.67
F=0.46		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.65
F=0.49		 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.69
F=0.55		 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.54
F=0.48
ID: 78004 Recall=0.60, Precision=0.66
F=0.63		 Recall=0.51, Precision=0.72
F=0.59		 Recall=0.39, Precision=0.81
F=0.52		 Recall=0.53, Precision=0.79
F=0.64
ID: 8023 Recall=0.42, Precision=0.16
F=0.23		 Recall=0.40, Precision=0.19
F=0.26		 Recall=0.40, Precision=0.19
F=0.25		 Recall=0.43, Precision=0.18
F=0.25
ID: 85048 Recall=0.58, Precision=0.61
F=0.59		 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.68
F=0.57		 Recall=0.56, Precision=0.73
F=0.64		 Recall=0.62, Precision=0.70
F=0.66
ID: 86000 Recall=0.46, Precision=0.51
F=0.49		 Recall=0.38, Precision=0.49
F=0.43		 Recall=0.36, Precision=0.58
F=0.45		 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.50
F=0.48
ID: 86016 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.51
F=0.48		 Recall=0.24, Precision=0.82
F=0.37		 Recall=0.22, Precision=0.95
F=0.35		 Recall=0.20, Precision=0.89
F=0.33
ID: 86068 Recall=0.33, Precision=0.33
F=0.33		 Recall=0.48, Precision=0.32
F=0.38		 Recall=0.52, Precision=0.28
F=0.36		 Recall=0.55, Precision=0.29
F=0.38
ID: 87046 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.46
F=0.47		 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.49
F=0.48		 Recall=0.41, Precision=0.59
F=0.48		 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.49
F=0.47
ID: 89072 Recall=0.47, Precision=0.44
F=0.46		 Recall=0.36, Precision=0.42
F=0.39		 Recall=0.49, Precision=0.44
F=0.46		 Recall=0.45, Precision=0.43
F=0.44
ID: 97033 Recall=0.61, Precision=0.55
F=0.58		 Recall=0.57, Precision=0.53
F=0.55		 Recall=0.54, Precision=0.55
F=0.54		 Recall=0.58, Precision=0.56
F=0.57